Sample question 1 · Guidelines for Responsible AI (28%)
Hargrove & Pellini LLP, a 120-attorney regional law firm, recently deployed an AI-powered contract review assistant that processes uploaded client documents. A paralegal reports that the tool surfaced a summary containing confidential settlement terms from a different client's matter — terms that were never part of the uploaded document. The IT security team suspects the AI model may be retaining and cross-contaminating data across user sessions. The firm's managing partner demands an immediate response, but the vendor's SLA allows up to 72 hours for incident acknowledgment. Outside counsel for the firm's malpractice insurer is asking whether the firm's acceptable use policy for AI tools addresses data isolation requirements. Given the active data privacy incident and the escalating business and legal exposure, which action should the firm's AI governance lead prioritize FIRST to contain risk and satisfy responsible AI obligations?
- A. Notify the malpractice insurer immediately and wait for their guidance before taking any technical action, to avoid voiding coverage.
- B. Suspend the AI tool's access to client matter data and initiate an incident review to determine whether the acceptable use policy requires data isolation controls for AI systems handling privileged information.
- C. Update the firm's acceptable use policy to retroactively include data isolation language, then resume normal AI tool operations while the vendor investigates.
- D. Request that the vendor provide a root cause analysis within the 72-hour SLA window and take no internal action until that report is received.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: B. Suspend the AI tool's access to client matter data and initiate an incident review to determine whether the acceptable use policy requires data isolation controls for AI systems handling privileged information.
[Domain 4 - Guidelines for Responsible AI, Subtopic 4 - Responsible AI - Area 1 - Data privacy] Core Concept: Identify security, compliance, and risk considerations. requires applying data privacy in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² exam outline. Correct Answer (B): Suspend the AI tool's access to client matter data and initiate an incident review to determine whether the acceptable use policy requires data isolation controls for AI systems handling privileged information. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Waiting for insurer guidance before taking technical action allows the data privacy incident to continue and may worsen legal exposure; containment is a firm's independent obligation regardless of insurance coordination. Option C: Retroactively updating the acceptable use policy does not address the active incident and resuming operations without root cause analysis exposes additional client matters to the same cross-contamination risk. Option D: Deferring entirely to the vendor's 72-hour SLA ignores the firm's independent duty to protect client confidentiality and delays containment actions that are within the firm's own control.