Sample question 1 · Assessing CMMC Level 2 Practices (40%)
Meridian Aerospace Components, a mid-sized defense subcontractor based in Ohio, recently acquired Vantage Precision Systems, a smaller CNC machining firm in Michigan. Following the acquisition, Meridian's CMMC assessment scope expanded to include Vantage's shop-floor network, which processes CUI-bearing technical drawings transmitted from a prime contractor. During the Phase 2 (Assessment) activities of the CAP, you discover that Vantage's network was integrated into Meridian's environment only six weeks before the assessment began. Vantage's IT staff report that access control policies were applied to the newly integrated subnet, but no formal documentation of those policy changes was generated at the time of integration. The Meridian CISO argues that because the integration was recent and operationally urgent, verbal confirmation from the IT director should suffice as evidence for AC.2 (Account Management). A production deadline tied to a major ITAR-controlled contract is three weeks away, and Meridian's leadership is pressuring the assessment team to accept informal attestations to avoid delays. As the lead CMMC assessor, how should you respond to the request to accept verbal confirmation from the IT director as the primary evidence object for AC.2 compliance in the newly integrated Vantage subnet?
- A. Accept the verbal confirmation as a supplemental interview artifact, but require corroborating documentation or system-generated records (such as access control configuration exports or change management tickets) before marking AC.2 as MET for the Vantage subnet.
- B. Accept the verbal confirmation as sufficient because the CMMC Level 2 Assessment Guide permits assessor discretion to substitute interview evidence when documentary evidence is unavailable due to recent operational changes.
- C. Defer the assessment of the Vantage subnet entirely until Meridian produces 90 days of documented evidence, consistent with standard audit evidence aging requirements for federal contractor assessments.
- D. Mark AC.2 as NOT MET immediately and issue a Plan of Action and Milestones (POA&M) without further evidence collection, since the absence of documentation at integration time constitutes a definitive control failure.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: A. Accept the verbal confirmation as a supplemental interview artifact, but require corroborating documentation or system-generated records (such as access control configuration exports or change management tickets) before marking AC.2 as MET for the Vantage subnet.
[Domain 4 - Assessing CMMC Level 2 Practices, Subtopic 4A - Evidence Verification and Validation - Area 1 - CMMC Level 2 Assessment Guide] Core Concept: The CMMC Level 2 Assessment Guide specifies three assessment object types — examine, interview, and test — and requires that assessors use a combination of these methods to validate practice implementation. Interview evidence (such as verbal confirmation) is a recognized assessment object, but it is not independently sufficient for practices where documentation or system-generated artifacts are expected; corroboration across multiple object types is the standard. Business pressure or operational urgency does not alter the evidentiary standard required to mark a practice as MET. Correct Answer (A): Accepting the verbal confirmation as an interview artifact while requiring corroborating examine-type evidence (e.g., configuration exports, change tickets, or account listings) correctly applies the multi-method validation principle from the CMMC Level 2 Assessment Guide. Correct Answer (A): Correct Answer (A): This approach neither dismisses the interview evidence nor allows it to stand alone, preserving assessment integrity while giving the OSC a fair opportunity to produce available artifacts before a final determination is made. Why the other options are incorrect: Why the other options are incorrect: Why the other options are incorrect: Option B: : : The CMMC Level 2 Assessment Guide does not grant assessors open-ended discretion to substitute interview evidence for examine or test evidence simply because documentation was not generated; each assessment object type serves a distinct validation purpose and operational urgency is not a recognized exception. Option C: : : CMMC does not impose a fixed 90-day evidence aging requirement; the assessment guide focuses on whether evidence demonstrates current implementation, and arbitrarily deferring the entire subnet assessment is not a prescribed CAP procedure. Option D: : : Issuing a POA&M without completing evidence collection is premature; the CAP requires assessors to exhaust available evidence-gathering methods across all three object types before rendering a MET or NOT MET determination, and a POA&M is a remediation planning tool, not a substitute for completing the assessment.