Sample question 1 · Scoping (15%)
Meridian Composites Group, a Canadian-owned manufacturer with a U.S. subsidiary in South Carolina, produces specialized materials for both commercial aerospace and U.S. defense programs. Following a contract review initiated by the U.S. subsidiary's legal team, the assessment scope was redetermined: only the Advanced Defense Materials (ADM) business unit within the U.S. subsidiary processes FCI under a DFARS-covered subcontract. The parent company in Canada and the U.S. subsidiary's commercial divisions are explicitly out of scope per the contract carve-out documentation. However, the ADM unit relies on a vendor-managed inventory (VMI) system operated by a U.S.-based third-party logistics provider, Crestline Supply Co., which automatically receives purchase order data — some of which contains FCI about defense program material quantities and delivery schedules — via an EDI interface. Crestline's EDI system is hosted on Crestline's own servers and is not part of Meridian's internal network. As the CCP on the assessment team, you must determine whether Crestline Supply Co.'s EDI system falls within the FCI asset scope for this assessment. Given that Crestline Supply Co.'s EDI system automatically receives FCI-containing purchase order data from the ADM unit, which action best reflects the CCP's responsibility in determining the FCI asset scope?
- A. Exclude Crestline Supply Co.'s EDI system from the FCI asset scope because the contract carve-out documentation limits the assessment boundary to the ADM business unit within the U.S. subsidiary, and Crestline is a separate legal entity.
- B. Include Crestline Supply Co.'s EDI system within the FCI asset scope for this assessment and require Meridian to immediately terminate the EDI interface until Crestline achieves CMMC certification.
- C. Identify Crestline Supply Co.'s EDI system as an external system that receives and stores FCI, document it as part of the scoping analysis, and advise the assessment team lead that Crestline's handling of FCI may require evaluation of applicable CMMC obligations or flow-down requirements, even though Crestline's systems are outside Meridian's direct control.
- D. Treat the EDI interface as a data transmission mechanism only and exclude Crestline's EDI system from FCI asset scope because purchase order data transmitted via EDI is transient and does not constitute FCI storage.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: C. Identify Crestline Supply Co.'s EDI system as an external system that receives and stores FCI, document it as part of the scoping analysis, and advise the assessment team lead that Crestline's handling of FCI may require evaluation of applicable CMMC obligations or flow-down requirements, even though Crestline's systems are outside Meridian's direct control.
[Domain 6 - Scoping, Subtopic 6B - FCI Asset Scoping - Area 1 - CMMC high-level scoping] Core Concept: FCI scoping requires the assessment team to trace where FCI flows beyond the assessed organization's internal boundary, including to external vendors and service providers who receive FCI as part of their contracted services. When FCI is transmitted to and stored by a third-party system — such as a VMI/EDI platform — that system becomes relevant to the scoping analysis even if it is outside the assessed organization's direct control. The CCP's role is to document these external FCI flows and surface them for the assessment team lead, not to unilaterally expand or contract the scope or direct remediation actions. Correct Answer (C): Crestline's EDI system receives FCI-containing purchase order data automatically, meaning it processes and likely stores FCI outside Meridian's environment. The CCP's appropriate action is to document this external FCI flow as part of the scoping analysis and bring it to the assessment team lead's attention, noting that Crestline may have CMMC obligations or that Meridian may need to address flow-down requirements in its subcontract with Crestline. Correct Answer (C): Correct Answer (C): This reflects the CCP's role as a supporting team member who identifies and documents scope-relevant findings rather than making unilateral determinations or directing remediation. Why the other options are incorrect: Why the other options are incorrect: Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: : : A contract carve-out defining the assessed organization's internal boundary does not eliminate the scoping obligation to identify external parties that receive FCI; the carve-out governs which Meridian business units are in scope, not whether third-party FCI flows must be documented. Option B: : : Requiring immediate termination of the EDI interface exceeds the CCP's authority as an assessment team member; the CCP supports the assessment process and documents findings but does not direct the organization to take specific remediation actions, particularly ones with significant operational impact. Option D: : : EDI systems that receive and store purchase order data containing FCI are not merely transient transmission mechanisms; the data is ingested and retained by Crestline's system, making the characterization of the flow as purely transient inaccurate and the exclusion from scoping analysis unjustified.