Sample question 1 · Legal, Risk and Compliance (13%)
Orynthia Pharma, a small specialty pharmaceutical company based in Ireland, uses a SaaS-based laboratory information management system (LIMS) hosted by a U.S.-based vendor, DataCore Solutions, to manage quality control records subject to EU GMP Chapter 4 documentation requirements. Orynthia's internal audit team is preparing for an Irish Health Products Regulatory Authority (HPRA) inspection and has requested DataCore's audit artifacts. DataCore provides a SOC 2 Type II report but includes a scope restriction statement indicating that the report covers only the physical and environmental security controls at its primary data center; logical access controls, change management, and data backup procedures for the SaaS application layer are explicitly out of scope. Orynthia's internal auditor must determine how to document this limitation in the audit planning workpapers and what additional evidence to gather. Which approach should Orynthia Pharma's internal auditor take to appropriately address the SOC 2 Type II scope restriction when preparing audit workpapers for the HPRA inspection?
- A. Document the scope restriction as an accepted risk in the audit workpapers and note that the SOC 2 Type II report satisfies the physical security requirements, then rely solely on Orynthia's own internal controls documentation to cover the out-of-scope application layer without further vendor engagement.
- B. Discard the SOC 2 Type II report entirely because it does not cover the application layer and request that DataCore Solutions obtain a full-scope SOC 2 Type II report before the HPRA inspection date.
- C. Perform a gap analysis comparing the out-of-scope control domains (logical access, change management, data backup) against Orynthia's own compensating controls and contractual obligations, document residual risks, and request supplemental evidence from DataCore—such as internal audit results, penetration test summaries, or a letter of attestation—to address the identified gaps in the audit workpapers.
- D. Escalate the scope restriction to the HPRA inspector proactively before the inspection and request that the regulator waive the requirement for third-party assurance over the SaaS application layer given the vendor's contractual data protection commitments.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: C. Perform a gap analysis comparing the out-of-scope control domains (logical access, change management, data backup) against Orynthia's own compensating controls and contractual obligations, document residual risks, and request supplemental evidence from DataCore—such as internal audit results, penetration test summaries, or a letter of attestation—to address the identified gaps in the audit workpapers.
[Domain 6 - Legal, Risk and Compliance, Task 6.3 - Understand audit processes, methodologies, and required adaptations for a cloud environment, Area 1 - Internal and external audit controls] Core Concept: Understand audit processes, methodologies, and required adaptations for a cloud environment requires applying internal and external audit controls in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² CCSP exam outline. Correct Answer (C): Perform a gap analysis comparing the out-of-scope control domains (logical access, change management, data backup) against Orynthia's own compensating controls and contractual obligations, document residual risks, and request supplemental evidence from DataCore—such as internal audit results, penetration test summaries, or a letter of attestation—to address the identified gaps in the audit workpapers. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Relying solely on internal controls documentation without engaging the vendor to address the out-of-scope application layer leaves a material assurance gap for logical access, change management, and backup—controls that are directly relevant to GMP data integrity requirements and would be scrutinized during an HPRA inspection. Option B: Discarding the existing SOC 2 Type II report eliminates valid assurance over physical and environmental controls and demanding a full-scope report may not be achievable within the inspection timeline; a more pragmatic approach is to supplement the existing report rather than replace it entirely. Option D: Proactively disclosing the limitation to the regulator before exhausting remediation options is premature and could unnecessarily trigger regulatory concern; regulators expect organizations to manage vendor assurance gaps through their own quality systems before escalating to the authority.