Sample question 1 · Incident Handling (25%)
Meridian Tri-County Bank, a regional bank operating across three states and subject to federal banking examination requirements, outsources its 24/7 security operations center (SOC) function to a firm called Fortis Sentinel Group under a multi-year managed detection and response contract. The contract requires Fortis Sentinel to generate a weekly security monitoring report summarizing all phishing-related SIEM alerts, including alert volume, severity distribution, and escalation actions taken. During a federal examiner's review, the examiner requests the last eight weeks of these reports. Fortis Sentinel produces only four reports, explaining that their analysts skipped report generation during weeks when alert volume was 'too low to be meaningful.' Meridian's internal technician is asked by the bank's CISO to assess the situation and recommend an immediate corrective step. Which corrective step should the Meridian technician recommend first to address the reporting gap identified by the federal examiner?
- A. Ask Fortis Sentinel to retroactively create the four missing reports using SIEM data from those weeks and submit them to the examiner as the official record.
- B. Recommend that Meridian's CISO issue a formal written notice to Fortis Sentinel citing the contractual reporting obligation, and simultaneously pull the available SIEM alert data for the missing weeks directly from the platform to reconstruct an accurate summary for the examiner.
- C. Advise the CISO to inform the examiner that the missing reports indicate no significant phishing activity occurred during those weeks and that no further action is needed.
- D. Suspend the Fortis Sentinel contract immediately and transfer all SIEM monitoring responsibilities to Meridian's internal IT team pending a full vendor audit.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: B. Recommend that Meridian's CISO issue a formal written notice to Fortis Sentinel citing the contractual reporting obligation, and simultaneously pull the available SIEM alert data for the missing weeks directly from the platform to reconstruct an accurate summary for the examiner.
[Domain 4 - Incident Handling, Subtopic 4 - Incident Handling - Area 1 - SIEM concepts] Core Concept: Describe security monitoring and reporting. requires applying siem concepts in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² CC exam outline. Correct Answer (B): Recommend that Meridian's CISO issue a formal written notice to Fortis Sentinel citing the contractual reporting obligation, and simultaneously pull the available SIEM alert data for the missing weeks directly from the platform to reconstruct an accurate summary for the examiner. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Asking the vendor to retroactively create official reports risks producing documents that misrepresent the original monitoring state and could constitute falsification of records submitted to a federal examiner, creating significant legal and regulatory liability. Option C: Telling the examiner that missing reports indicate no significant activity is an unsupported assumption — low alert volume does not mean no alerts existed — and misrepresents the bank's monitoring posture to a regulator, which is a serious compliance violation. Option D: Immediately suspending the vendor contract without management authorization exceeds the technician's authority and could disrupt 24/7 monitoring coverage during an active regulatory examination, creating additional operational and compliance risk.