Sample question 1 · Diagnosis (20%)
Thornwick Power Authority, a large investor-owned electric utility operating across three states, experienced a partial network outage at its eastern transmission control center at 11:47 PM on a Tuesday. Two energy management system (EMS) servers lost communication with a cluster of remote terminal units (RTUs) located 340 miles away at a high-voltage switching yard. The incident has been escalated to Tier 2 support technician Marcus, who is working remotely. Marcus can reach the switching yard's local router via SSH but cannot reach the RTU cluster subnet (192.168.77.0/24). He needs to determine at which network hop the communication path is failing so the field crew can be dispatched to the correct location, minimizing business impact during peak overnight load balancing operations. Marcus has already confirmed via ping that the RTU cluster subnet is unreachable from the EMS servers. He now needs to identify the specific network hop where the path breaks down between the control center and the switching yard. Which tool should Marcus use next, and what information will it provide?
- A. Run ipconfig on the EMS server to display its IP address, subnet mask, and default gateway, confirming the server's local network configuration is correct.
- B. Use a cable tester on the fiber patch panel at the control center to verify signal continuity on the WAN uplink connecting to the switching yard.
- C. Run traceroute targeting 192.168.77.1 from the EMS server to display each intermediate router hop and the point at which responses stop being returned.
- D. Run ping repeatedly with increasing packet sizes to the switching yard router to stress-test the WAN link and identify bandwidth saturation.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: C. Run traceroute targeting 192.168.77.1 from the EMS server to display each intermediate router hop and the point at which responses stop being returned.
[Domain 5 - Diagnosis, Subtopic 5 - Diagnosis - Area 1 - ping] Core Concept: Use basic diagnostic tools and methodologies. requires applying ping in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² CC exam outline. Correct Answer (C): Run traceroute targeting 192.168.77.1 from the EMS server to display each intermediate router hop and the point at which responses stop being returned. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Running ipconfig on the EMS server checks the server's own local addressing, which is a useful early diagnostic step but has already been implicitly validated since Marcus confirmed the subnet is unreachable — the problem is clearly in the path beyond the local host, not in the EMS server's own configuration. Option B: A cable tester checks physical layer continuity and is appropriate for short copper or fiber patch cables in a local environment, but Marcus is working remotely and the WAN link spans 340 miles, making a physical cable test at the control center patch panel irrelevant to diagnosing a routing path failure at a distant hop. Option D: Sending ping packets with increasing sizes is a technique sometimes used to test MTU or path fragmentation issues, not to identify which hop in a multi-router path is dropping traffic; this approach would not provide the hop-by-hop visibility that Marcus needs to direct the field crew.