Sample question 1 · Governance & Management of IT
The Ridgecroft County Department of Social Services recently migrated its legacy case management system to a cloud-based platform operated by a third-party vendor, CloudServe Solutions. The contract was executed under an emergency procurement waiver due to budget cycle pressures, bypassing the standard vendor evaluation committee. Eighteen months into the contract, an IS auditor reviewing vendor management practices discovers that: (1) no formal security assessment of CloudServe was conducted prior to contract award; (2) the contract contains no data residency clauses despite the department handling federally protected beneficiary data; (3) CloudServe's subcontractor, DataVault Inc., processes backup data in an offshore jurisdiction without the department's knowledge; and (4) the department's IT manager verbally approved the subcontracting arrangement after the fact. The department's legal counsel confirms that the offshore processing likely violates the state's data sovereignty statute. Given the audit findings, which control gap represents the MOST significant risk to the department's compliance posture and should be the primary focus of the IS auditor's remediation recommendation?
- A. The absence of a formal security assessment prior to contract award, because it prevented the department from evaluating CloudServe's technical controls before granting access to sensitive systems.
- B. The lack of data residency and subcontracting oversight clauses in the contract, because it created an unenforceable legal position against a vendor arrangement that currently violates state data sovereignty law.
- C. The verbal approval of the subcontracting arrangement by the IT manager, because it bypassed the department's change management process and created an undocumented governance decision.
- D. The use of an emergency procurement waiver, because it circumvented the vendor evaluation committee and established a pattern of bypassing established governance controls.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: B. The lack of data residency and subcontracting oversight clauses in the contract, because it created an unenforceable legal position against a vendor arrangement that currently violates state data sovereignty law.
[Domain 2 - Governance & Management of IT, Subtopic B - IT Management - Area 2 - IT Vendor Management] Core Concept: In vendor contract management, the enforceability of contractual protections is the foundational mechanism through which an organization can compel vendor compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. Correct Answer (B): The lack of data residency and subcontracting oversight clauses in the contract, because it created an unenforceable legal position against a vendor arrangement that currently violates state data sovereignty law. While all four findings represent genuine control gaps, the absence of data residency and subcontracting oversight clauses is the most critical because it has already produced a confirmed statutory violation - offshore processing of protected beneficiary data - for which the department currently has no contractual remedy. Without enforceable contract language, the department cannot legally compel CloudServe to cease the arrangement, seek indemnification, or impose penalties Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Though important, addresses a pre-contract evaluation gap that is now historical; the more urgent issue is the active compliance breach. Option C: Is a governance process failure but is secondary to the legal exposure it enabled. Option D: While a root cause, is also historical and does not directly address the ongoing statutory violation. ISACA's IT vendor management framework emphasizes that contracts must explicitly address legal and regulatory requirements - including data handling, subcontracting rights, and jurisdiction - as the primary instrument for managing third-party risk.