Sample question 1 · Secure Software Supply Chain (10%)
Crestline Energy Co., a large investor-owned electric utility headquartered in the Pacific Northwest, uses a cloud-hosted SCADA data historian provided by Orinex Cloud Solutions. Orinex markets the service as compliant with NERC CIP and IEC 62443, but when Crestline's application security team requests supporting documentation, Orinex provides only a marketing brochure citing those standards. The vendor's master service agreement (MSA) does not obligate Orinex to share audit reports or assessment findings. Crestline's CISO has asked the application security lead to determine whether the historian service meets the utility's third-party software security requirements before renewing the three-year contract. Which approach should the application security lead recommend to most effectively evaluate the security of the Orinex cloud historian service prior to contract renewal?
- A. Request that Orinex provide a Cloud Controls Matrix (CCM) self-assessment or a third-party audit report (e.g., SOC 2 Type II or CSA STAR) covering the historian service, and incorporate a right-to-audit clause in the renewed MSA.
- B. Accept the vendor's marketing brochure as a declaration of compliance and proceed with renewal, noting the claimed standards alignment in the vendor risk register.
- C. Conduct an internal red-team exercise against Crestline's own network perimeter to validate that the historian service cannot be reached from external threat actors.
- D. Replace the cloud historian with an on-premises solution to avoid the complexity of evaluating cloud-based third-party software security.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: A. Request that Orinex provide a Cloud Controls Matrix (CCM) self-assessment or a third-party audit report (e.g., SOC 2 Type II or CSA STAR) covering the historian service, and incorporate a right-to-audit clause in the renewed MSA.
[Domain 8 - Secure Software Supply Chain, Task 8.2 - Analyze security of third-party software, Area 2 - Assessment reports (e.g., cloud controls matrix)] Core Concept: Analyze security of third-party software requires applying assessment reports (e.g., cloud controls matrix) in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² CSSLP exam outline. Correct Answer (A): Request that Orinex provide a Cloud Controls Matrix (CCM) self-assessment or a third-party audit report (e.g., SOC 2 Type II or CSA STAR) covering the historian service, and incorporate a right-to-audit clause in the renewed MSA. Why the other options are incorrect: Option B: A marketing brochure is not a certification or assessment report and provides no independently verified evidence of security control effectiveness; accepting it as compliance documentation would leave Crestline unable to substantiate its third-party risk posture to regulators or auditors. Option C: A red-team exercise against Crestline's own perimeter tests network boundary controls but does not evaluate the security of the Orinex historian service itself, including its internal architecture, data handling, access controls, or development practices. Option D: Migrating to an on-premises solution is a significant architectural decision that does not address the immediate contract renewal question and does not fulfill the application security lead's responsibility to analyze the security of the existing third-party software before a renewal decision is made.