Sample question 1 · Reporting and Communication (17%)
Crestline Savings Bank, a small community bank with a single headquarters and seven branches in a rural region, has engaged a third-party managed security service to perform monthly vulnerability assessments. Following a credential theft incident traced to a phishing campaign, the latest assessment report shows a mean time to remediate (MTTR) critical vulnerabilities of 47 days against an internal SLO target of 14 days. The bank's IT team consists of two administrators who also handle help desk duties. The compliance officer has flagged that the bank's written information security program (WISP) requires critical vulnerabilities to be remediated within 14 days. The IT director argues that the two-person team cannot meet the SLO without additional staffing or tooling. As the security analyst responsible for vulnerability management reporting, what should you recommend to BEST communicate the KPI/SLO gap and its governance implications to senior leadership?
- A. Revise the SLO in the WISP from 14 days to 60 days to align with the team's demonstrated capacity, then report the revised metric as compliant in the next executive summary.
- B. Present the 47-day MTTR alongside the 14-day SLO target in the executive report, quantify the compliance risk created by the gap, identify understaffing as a documented inhibitor to remediation, and recommend a risk acceptance decision or resource investment with a corrective action plan.
- C. Report the MTTR metric only to the managed security service provider and omit it from the internal executive report until the IT team can demonstrate improvement.
- D. Instruct the IT administrators to prioritize only the highest CVSS-scored vulnerability per month and mark all others as accepted risk without formal documentation to reduce the apparent backlog.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: B. Present the 47-day MTTR alongside the 14-day SLO target in the executive report, quantify the compliance risk created by the gap, identify understaffing as a documented inhibitor to remediation, and recommend a risk acceptance decision or resource investment with a corrective action plan.
[Domain 4 - Reporting and Communication, Subtopic 4 - Reporting and Communication - Area 1 - Risk scores] Core Concept: Explain the importance of vulnerability management reporting and communication. centers on risk scores as defined in the official (ISC)² exam outline. Correct Answer (B): Present the 47-day MTTR alongside the 14-day SLO target in the executive report, quantify the compliance risk created by the gap, identify understaffing as a documented inhibitor to remediation, and recommend a risk acceptance decision or resource investment with a corrective action plan. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Retroactively revising the SLO to match poor performance without a formal governance review and risk assessment circumvents the purpose of the metric and could expose the bank to regulatory criticism for weakening its own written security program. Option C: Withholding the MTTR metric from internal executive reporting deprives senior leadership of material risk information and undermines the governance function that vulnerability management reporting is designed to support. Option D: Informally accepting risk on the majority of vulnerabilities without documentation violates the bank's WISP, creates untracked residual risk, and does not constitute a defensible risk management practice under regulatory scrutiny.