Sample question 1 · Secure Operations, Change Management and Disposal (14%)
Northgate Children's Hospital, a 120-bed pediatric facility in suburban Ohio, is recovering from a ransomware attack that disabled its pharmacy management system. The pharmacy director has requested an emergency change to temporarily allow nurses to manually override medication dispensing cabinet locks using a universal master code — a capability that was previously disabled as a security control because it bypasses audit logging. The hospital's ethics committee has flagged the request, noting that disabling audit logging for controlled substances may violate DEA 21 CFR Part 1304 record-keeping requirements. The systems security engineer is asked to participate in the change review board meeting scheduled for the following morning. The change request form lists no compensating controls and no impact assessment. As the systems security engineer participating in the change review board, what is the most appropriate engineering action to take before the board approves or rejects this change?
- A. Advise the board to approve the change with no modifications, since DEA record-keeping requirements are a legal matter outside the security engineer's scope and the pharmacy director has operational authority over dispensing procedures.
- B. Recommend that the board table the change indefinitely until the pharmacy management system is fully restored, because any change that disables audit logging cannot be approved under any circumstances.
- C. Perform an impact assessment of the proposed change, document the regulatory risk under DEA 21 CFR Part 1304 and the loss of audit trail as a security control gap, propose compensating controls such as manual paper-based dispensing logs countersigned by two staff members, and update the risk register with the residual risk and required executive and legal sign-off.
- D. Instruct the pharmacy director to implement the master code override immediately without board review, since the ransomware incident constitutes a declared emergency that suspends all change management requirements.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: C. Perform an impact assessment of the proposed change, document the regulatory risk under DEA 21 CFR Part 1304 and the loss of audit trail as a security control gap, propose compensating controls such as manual paper-based dispensing logs countersigned by two staff members, and update the risk register with the residual risk and required executive and legal sign-off.
[Domain 5 - Secure Operations, Change Management and Disposal, Task 5.3 - Participate in change management, Area 1 - Participate in change reviews] Core Concept: Participate in change management requires applying participate in change reviews in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² ISSEP exam outline. Correct Answer (C): Perform an impact assessment of the proposed change, document the regulatory risk under DEA 21 CFR Part 1304 and the loss of audit trail as a security control gap, propose compensating controls such as manual paper-based dispensing logs countersigned by two staff members, and update the risk register with the residual risk and required executive and legal sign-off. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Treating DEA regulatory compliance as outside the security engineer's scope is incorrect; regulatory requirements directly inform the security control baseline, and the engineer must surface compliance risks during change reviews even when operational staff hold authority over procedures. Option B: Tabling the change indefinitely without offering compensating controls ignores the patient safety imperative and fails to fulfill the engineer's role of recommending risk-reducing alternatives that allow operations to continue within an acceptable risk boundary. Option D: Bypassing the change review board entirely contradicts the fundamental purpose of change management; even declared emergencies require documented review, impact assessment, and risk acceptance — the engineer's role is to expedite that process, not eliminate it.