Sample question 1 · Network Troubleshooting (24%)
Hartwell & Crane LLP, a mid-sized law firm with 120 attorneys across two floors, recently deployed IP phones at every workstation as part of a unified communications rollout. The network team ran new horizontal cabling from the IDF to each desk, reusing a spool of Cat5e cable they found in storage. After installation, attorneys on the second floor report that their IP phones power on intermittently and drop calls frequently, while first-floor phones operate normally. The network administrator checks the switch and confirms that all second-floor ports are configured for PoE. Cable lengths on both floors are under 80 meters. The administrator then uses a cable certifier on a sample of second-floor runs and discovers that the wire pairs do not meet the current TIA-568 standard for PoE power delivery. Which physical layer issue MOST likely explains why the second-floor IP phones are experiencing intermittent power and call drops despite the switch ports being PoE-enabled?
- A. The Cat5e cable in storage is rated for data transmission but lacks the conductor gauge and pair resistance specifications required to sustain PoE current over the run lengths used, causing voltage drop and intermittent device power.
- B. The switch ports on the second-floor IDF are configured for 802.3af instead of 802.3at, limiting available wattage to the IP phones and causing them to reset under load.
- C. The IP phones are experiencing crosstalk from adjacent data cables in the same conduit, which disrupts the PoE negotiation signal and causes the phones to lose power.
- D. The second-floor runs exceed the maximum segment length for PoE delivery, causing attenuation of the DC power signal before it reaches the powered devices.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: A. The Cat5e cable in storage is rated for data transmission but lacks the conductor gauge and pair resistance specifications required to sustain PoE current over the run lengths used, causing voltage drop and intermittent device power.
[Domain 5 - Network Troubleshooting, Subtopic 5 - Network Troubleshooting - Area 1 - Cable type mismatches] Core Concept: Given a scenario, troubleshoot common cabling and physical interface issues. centers on cable type mismatches as defined in the official (ISC)² exam outline. Correct Answer (A): The Cat5e cable in storage is rated for data transmission but lacks the conductor gauge and pair resistance specifications required to sustain PoE current over the run lengths used, causing voltage drop and intermittent device power. Why the other options are incorrect: Option B: While an 802.3af vs. 802.3at mismatch could limit wattage, the scenario states the administrator confirmed PoE is configured on all ports and the cable certifier — not a switch audit — revealed the root cause; a PoE standard mismatch would not be detected by a cable certifier flagging TIA-568 pair resistance failures. Option C: Crosstalk affects data signal integrity and would manifest as CRC errors or reduced throughput, not as intermittent power loss; PoE power delivery operates on DC current across all four pairs and is not disrupted by near-end crosstalk in the way data signals are. Option D: The scenario explicitly states all cable runs are under 80 meters, well within the 100-meter channel limit; PoE voltage drop is governed by conductor resistance, not segment length alone, and the cable certifier finding points to resistance specification failure rather than an excessive-length violation.