Sample question 1 · Design security solutions for applications and data (20–25%)
Aldenvale University, a small liberal arts institution with approximately 4,000 students, recently experienced a malware infection that spread through a misconfigured endpoint in the university's digital archives department. The archives department maintains digitized historical records, donor financial records, and alumni personally identifiable information in a single on-premises file server with no sensitivity labeling. Following the incident, the university's Board of Trustees has convened an emergency session and is demanding that the CISO present a clear communication to external stakeholders — including alumni associations and a regional accreditation body — explaining what data was at risk and what architectural controls will be implemented to prevent recurrence. The CISO has engaged the cybersecurity architect to design a data security solution that can also serve as the basis for the stakeholder communication. The architect must identify the control that most directly enables the university to answer the question: 'What sensitive data did the malware have access to?' As the cybersecurity architect at Aldenvale University, which architectural control should you recommend first to enable the CISO to answer the Board's question and form the basis of the stakeholder communication?
- A. Deploy an endpoint detection and response agent on all university endpoints to capture process execution telemetry and reconstruct the malware's lateral movement path across the network.
- B. Implement network segmentation to isolate the archives department file server from other university systems, preventing future malware from traversing between departments.
- C. Conduct a structured data discovery and classification assessment of the archives file server to produce an authoritative inventory of sensitive data categories present, their volume, and their regulatory classification, which directly answers the stakeholder question about data at risk.
- D. Engage a third-party managed security service provider to perform continuous threat monitoring of the archives environment and provide monthly risk reports to the Board of Trustees.
View answer & explanation
Correct answer: C. Conduct a structured data discovery and classification assessment of the archives file server to produce an authoritative inventory of sensitive data categories present, their volume, and their regulatory classification, which directly answers the stakeholder question about data at risk.
[Domain 4 - Design security solutions for applications and data, Subtopic 4 - Applications and Data Security - Area 1 - Data discovery/classification] Core Concept: Design solutions for securing an organization's data. requires applying data discovery/classification in the context of the scenario, consistent with the official (ISC)² exam outline. Correct Answer (C): Conduct a structured data discovery and classification assessment of the archives file server to produce an authoritative inventory of sensitive data categories present, their volume, and their regulatory classification, which directly answers the stakeholder question about data at risk. Why the other options are incorrect: Option A: Endpoint detection and response telemetry reconstructs the malware's behavior and movement path but does not identify what categories of sensitive data resided on the file server or were accessible; it answers 'what did the malware do' rather than 'what data was at risk.'. Option B: Network segmentation is a valid preventive control for future incidents but does not address the current gap — the absence of a data inventory — and provides no information to support the stakeholder communication about data exposure during the existing incident. Option D: Engaging a managed security service provider for continuous monitoring is an operational control that addresses future threat detection but does not produce the data classification inventory needed to answer the Board's immediate question or support the required external stakeholder communication.